Penn State The Mentor: An Academic Advising Journal

   Current Issue
   About the Journal
   Advising Forum
   Archives
   Bookstore
   Calendar of Events
   Et Cetera
   Guest Book
   Indexes
   Major Changers
   The Muse
   The Portable Mentor
   Search
   Submitting Articles
   Subscribing
   Updates
   Writing Competition
   mentor@psu.edu



book   Advising Forum


  Topic from May 2007
How do you motivate your advisees? What techniques or strategies do you use to engage advisees in the teaching-advising process? How can advisers increase their chances of getting results from their advising strategies? What can advisers do to encourage students to make, prepare for, and keep advising appointments? How can advisers get students to follow through on suggestions, such as attending advising-related events? What's your opinion?

  Readers' Responses

leaf  My initial feelings are that a student really has to motivate themselves to succeed. I can be a coach, a mentor, and a friend to them during this process. However, they have to want to succeed and be willing to do what it takes. What do I do? Well, I challenge them and ask them to bring the “right” questions to our meetings. I ask them to challenge themselves, set the bar high, and to always give their all. I use respect as the foundation of this dialogue and try to keep them focused on their mission. This mission (to complete college) is the guiding goal of our relationship.

How do I know my efforts are working? Well, I ask students many questions. I ask them to stay focused. I ask them to see the end result of their goals. I have told many first- and second-year students to attend graduation this weekend. They need to visualize their success. This success is created through their efforts. A proactive, developmental adviser can be an important part of their journey. When an adviser “connects” with a student through a respectful approach, then that relationship can create a sense of obligation. Students will attend their appointment, come prepared for the appointment, and gain valuable experience in the etiquette of professional practices.

Keith Rocci, The University of Arizona, May 8, 2007



leaf  Almost all of the appointments that I see are based on three questions (I frame in different ways, depending on the student):
  1. What do you want?
  2. What's holding you back from getting what you want?
  3. What are you going to do about it (and how can I help)?
The purpose is to get the student to take responsibility for completing a particular task, not for me to do it for them. If I have knowledge/expertise in a particular area, I will share; if not, I will help get them started, but leave it up to them. Instead of teaching all students to make positive change, I try to teach just one at a time . . . and have him or her share the experience with others. Eventually, the best route is to have them teach each other and hold each other accountable—then I can go on vacation!

Bill Johnson, College of William and Mary, May 8, 2007



leaf  While I might overuse John Dewey, I take to heart my attitudes necessary for working with students for me to be open-minded, wholehearted, and responsible. Through those attitudes comes a sense of caring and concern for the welfare of my students. I know I must be seen as the “good helper,” according to Donald Super. To motivate students, I must be seen as open, honest, and informed. I always start by saying, “let's think big and when you're thinking big, let's think bigger.” Be positive and talk about their highest hopes. It works!

Barbara K. Wade, Ph.D., Penn State University, May 10, 2007



leaf  I do advising based on one principle, “When person succeed, they get motivated.” In first meeting I ask questions about students' liking and disliking about a course and rank courses from easy to difficult. First semester, I recommend them to take easy courses, when they get succeed in those courses, they believe in themselves and me. After that it is easy to motivate them.

Neeru Deep, Northwestern State University of Louisiana, May 17, 2007


The Mentor is published by Penn State's Division of Undergraduate Studies
Available online at www.psu.edu/dus/mentor/
Privacy and Legal Statements | Copyright | © The Pennsylvania State University | All rights reserved