Penn State The Mentor: An Academic Advising Journal

   Current Issue
   About the Journal
   Advising Forum
   Archives
   Bookstore
   Calendar of Events
   Et Cetera
   Guest Book
   Indexes
   Major Changers
   The Muse
   The Portable Mentor
   Search
   Submitting Articles
   Subscribing
   Updates
   Writing Competition
   mentor@psu.edu



book   Advising Forum


  Topic from April 2008
This month, the Advising Forum presents the twenty-second in a series of advising case studies. The first six case studies were published in the journal in May–October 2000, with two other six-part series published in 2002 and 2004.

Case study #22—A lifting encounter

On a weekend visit to the mall, you catch sight of one of your advisees. Just as you start to approach her to say hello, you see her slip something into her pocket and leave the store unnoticed. Are you legally, morally, or ethically bound to report her? If she's convicted of shoplifting, even if it's a misdemeanor, she might be ineligible to obtain her teacher certification, something she's worked hard for and is close to obtaining. Is it worth losing a potentially good teacher, for example, over a stolen roll of mints? What if it's a more serious shoplifting offense—a felony, for example? What would you do in this case, and why?

  Readers' Responses

leaf  I would walk up to her, greet her in a friendly way, and gently confront the problem, trying to convince her to go back to the store and return the item. If she agreed, I would watch her do it, then help her initiate professional counseling back on campus.

If she refused to take back the item, I would turn her in. Why? Because that could signal dangerously addictive behavior demanding firm intervention, even for someone who is not a prospective teacher.

Jan Haluska, professor of English, Southern Adventist University, April 4, 2008



leaf  As an adviser, I believe that one has the responsibility to address the situation, immediately if possible. This could provide for a unique learning experience for both the adviser and the student. If handled properly, with sincere care and concern, the possibility exists to strengthen the adviser-advisee relationship. Also, additional information may come to light, helping the adviser determine if this is routine behavior or a sign of other issues.

George Mikluscak, campus director, West Virginia Career Institute, April 18, 2008


The Mentor is published by Penn State's Division of Undergraduate Studies
Available online at www.psu.edu/dus/mentor/
Privacy and Legal Statements | Copyright | © The Pennsylvania State University | All rights reserved