Research

Developing better starter cultures for high-quality cacao bean fermentation

Funded by an award from the U.S. Department of State, Penn State food scientists and collaborators in Hawaii and Ecuador will work to enhance regionally adapted chocolate-making processes

Fulbright Scholar Joel Tigrero-Vaca examines a microscope slide containing the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, an important microorganism crucial during early stages of cocoa bean fermentation, with Helene Hopfer, associate professor of food science (right) and Josephine Wee, Lester Earl and Veronica Casida Career Development Professor for Food Safety, looking on. Credit: Andrew Lin / Penn State. All Rights Reserved.

UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — A team of researchers at Penn State will identify and compare key microbial communities in cacao fermentation, a vital transformative process that helps freshly harvested cacao beans turn into chocolate, to develop an adaptable starter culture — a cocktail of live microorganisms to kick-start and guide the fermentation process. The study, focused on fermenting high-quality cacao beans in Ecuador and Hawaii, will be funded by an agreement with the U.S. Department of State.

The agreement comes through the University of Hawai’i at Mānoa, which was selected by the U.S. Department of State to host and lead a new Feed the Future Innovation Lab for Coffee and Cacao (CCIL); the program is co-led by Clemson University in South Carolina. This agreement of up to five years included an initial obligation of $8 million for the first year, with the possibility of an extension.

Cacao fermentation — in which naturally occurring microorganisms such as yeast and bacteria grow and interact with the beans, breaking down sugars and producing alcohols, acids and many other flavorful compounds — currently relies on spontaneous microbial interactions. Those changes often result in inconsistencies affecting cacao quality and export value, according to team leader and co-principal investigator at Penn State Helene Hopfer, associate professor of food science in the College of Agricultural Sciences.

“Commercial starter cultures use a one-fits-all approach and are unable to replicate the unique contribution of local microbial communities to region-specific chocolate flavor development,” she said. “By developing regionally adaptable cultures for both a massive export economy like Ecuador and a high-value niche market like Hawaii, this project could provide scalable solutions that protect and enhance the economic value of fine-flavor cacao.”

Co-principal investigator Josephine Wee, Lester Earl and Veronica Casida Career Development Professor for Food Safety, has collaborated with cacao fermentation expert Juan Manuel Cevallos Cevallos, professor at Polytechnic University of the Litoral (ESPOL) in Guayaquil, Ecuador. Their work has focused on how to make the cacao fermentation process more consistent.

Chocolate comes from cacao beans developed in seed pods like these, growing in Hawaii. Penn State faculty have conducted research on cacao and chocolate for more than 50 years, covering a wide range of topics.  Credit: University of Hawai’i at Mānoa. All Rights Reserved.

One of Cevallos’ former master’s degree students, Joel Tigrero-Vaca, recently joined Penn State’s Department of Food Science as a doctoral student to gain more skills working with food microbiomes under the guidance of Wee, a faculty affiliate with the Huck Institutes of the Life Sciences One Health Microbiome Center. Funded by the Fulbright Scholar Program, Tigrero-Vaca will work on the CCIL program with Wee and Hopfer.

“We intend to identify the microorganisms responsible for consistently good fermentation and use them as a starter culture,” Wee said. “Our goal is to preserve some of the unique characteristics of local fermentation rather than replacing the local microbial ecosystem with a generic commercial culture. We don't necessarily want one universal starter culture — we want to develop cultures that work well in particular regions.”

Why some cacao fermentations produce exceptional chocolate while others fall short remains an important question for the industry. To address this, the research team will compare cacao fermentation in Ecuador and Hawaii, where naturally occurring microbial communities may differ significantly. Wee noted that these differences can exist not only between countries but also among cacao-producing regions within Ecuador.

The team will collect fermentation samples from multiple locations and compare microbial profiles from high- and low-quality fermentations. High-quality cacao fermentation transforms raw beans into complex flavor precursors, whereas low-quality — under-fermented or spoiled — fermentation results in flat, harsh and bitter flavor profiles. The researchers’ goal is to pinpoint the microorganisms most closely linked to consistently successful fermentation and superior chocolate quality.

To identify the microorganisms involved in cacao fermentation, the team will combine laboratory and genetic analyses to create a comprehensive picture of the microbial communities present during fermentation. This approach will help researchers to determine which microorganisms are consistently associated with high-quality fermentations and desirable chocolate characteristics.

The researchers then will characterize the chemical compounds produced by the microbes during fermentation and determine which microbes are present, the aroma compounds they produce, and which microbes and compounds are associated with high-quality cacao fermentation. Then they will build a synthetic microbial community — an artificially constructed group of microorganisms working together — to test if microbes responsible for high-quality fermentation in different areas can work together to improve results.

Cacao beans are bitter until they undergo fermentation—in which naturally occurring microorganisms such as yeast and bacteria grow and interact with the beans, breaking down sugars and producing alcohols, acids and many other flavorful compounds that contribute to the taste of chocolate. Credit: Synergistic Hawaiʻi Agriculture Council. All Rights Reserved.

Penn State’s connection to cacao and chocolate

Penn State faculty have conducted research on cacao and chocolate for more than 50 years, covering a wide range of topics including health benefits, aspects of cacao production, plant genetic improvement, plant propagation, soil management, flavor and quality, sensory science, chocolate making, agricultural extension and technology-transfer issues.

In 1986, the American Cocoa Research Institute and the Chocolate Manufacturers Association, comprising trade organizations representing the chocolate industry, contributed $1.5 million to create an endowment to support Penn State research on Theobroma cacao — the cocoa tree. At the time, the use of biotechnology to improve plants was still in its infancy.

Over the four decades since then, researchers have leveraged this funding to attract nearly $5 million in additional support for cacao science from organizations such as the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) and the U.S. National Science Foundation (NSF). Not only has the endowment grown, Hopfer said, but so has the scientific knowledge that is helping to promote economic security for cocoa farmers around the world and to ensure a reliable supply of the raw material needed to manufacture one of the world’s favorite delicacies.

The Cacao and Chocolate Research Network at Penn State currently includes more than 30 members, including international graduate students, postdoctoral fellows and faculty who are actively conducting cacao and chocolate research supported by funding from NSF, USDA, the chocolate industry and others. Faculty founded the network, but graduate students and postdoctoral fellows support and drive it.

Also, the Department of Food Science has offered the Chocolate Short Course for more than 30 years. After the retirement of long-time short course manager Greg Ziegler, distinguished professor emeritus of food science, who remains involved, Hopfer began overseeing the course.

Joel Tigrero-Vaca examines two Petri plates containing colonies of non-Saccharomyces yeasts, which are important in cocoa bean fermentation for final cocoa and chocolate quality.  Credit: Andrew Lin/Penn State. All Rights Reserved.

Feed the Future Coffee and Cacao Innovation Lab

The Coffee and Cacao Innovation Lab is a U.S. university-led collaborative agricultural research program that leverages the advanced capacities of American institutions to meet global challenges in coffee and cacao research. It will work with small farmers in Hawaii, the continental U.S. and in Latin America, Africa and Asia.

The initiative is intended to strengthen America’s economy because more than 99% of America’s coffee and cacao supply is imported. Protecting the health and productivity of these crops abroad and in Hawaii protects American businesses, consumers and growers, according to Parwinder Grewal, dean and director of the University of Hawai’i Mānoa College of Tropical Agriculture and Human Resilience and CCIL principal investigator.

The typical U.S. resident eats up to eight pounds of chocolate a year, and chocolate generates $28.4 billion in sales and adds 700,000 jobs to the U.S. economy, according to the National Confectioners Association. Yet the American roasting and confectionery industries depend almost entirely on a stable, high-quality supply from producing countries abroad.

A more resilient global supply, enabled by CCIL research, will help strengthen U.S. security, economic and trade interests while reinforcing America’s leadership in coffee and cacao research and production, Grewal said.

Beyond Penn State, the innovation lab features a world-class consortium of partners, including Michigan State University, Ohio State University, University of California, Davis, Coffee Quality Institute, Mars, Incorporated, PlantVillage+, Synergistic Hawaiʻi Agriculture Council and World Coffee Research.

The study will be funded by an agreement with the U.S. Department of State. The agreement comes through the University of Hawai’i at Mānoa, which was selected by the U.S. Department of State to host and lead a new Feed the Future Innovation Lab for Coffee and Cacao. Credit: U.S. Department of State. All Rights Reserved.

Contact